Not All Israel Is Israel (Romans 9:6)
The Question We Dare Not Ask
Could modern Israel be part of an end-times deception?
A provocative reflection on Revelation 16, Armageddon, Romans 9:6 and the meaning of Israel.
Overheard in a Molue
I’ve been thinking…
Could the emergence of Israel as a nation in 1948 be one of the greatest “false signs and wonders” of modern times?
Could the Israel we see today be a false Israel, raised up as part of an end-times deception to mislead many?
It is a provocative theological question, certainly, but one I think is worth exploring carefully.
As I’ve repeatedly argued, the Antichrist does not merely oppose Christ. He seeks to replace Christ, to receive the worship due to Christ and, ultimately, to deceive people into believing that he is Christ, or that what comes from him comes from God.
If that is the nature of the deception, then perhaps the most powerful false sign would not look obviously evil at all.
Perhaps it would look biblical.
Perhaps it would appear to fulfil prophecy.
Perhaps it would be convincing precisely because believers desperately want to believe it is from God.
That is the theological concept I want to explore.
Who’s bold enough to peep behind the veil?
I’ll circle back to this…
The Frogs
There is a passage in Revelation that has troubled me for a long time.
John writes:
“And I saw, coming out of the mouth of the dragon and out of the mouth of the beast and out of the mouth of the false prophet, three unclean spirits like frogs.”
Revelation 16:13
Then he tells us what these spirits do:
“For they are demonic spirits, performing signs, who go abroad to the kings of the whole world, to assemble them for battle on the great day of God the Almighty.”
Revelation 16:14
And finally:
“And they assembled them at the place that in Hebrew is called Armageddon.”
Revelation 16:16
Look carefully at the sequence:
Dragon + Beast + False Prophet
↓
Deceptive spirits
↓
Signs
↓
Kings of the earth influenced and gathered
↓
War
↓
Armageddon
That sequence has given me considerable concern.
Because the road to Armageddon, in John’s vision, is not simply a road paved by obviously evil men announcing obviously evil intentions.
There is deception involved.
There are signs.
There is persuasion.
And somehow the rulers of the earth become participants in something whose true spiritual character they apparently do not understand.
That brings me back to the provocative question I overheard in the Molue:
Could the Israel we see today be a false Israel, raised up as part of an end-times deception to mislead many?
Scripture does not explicitly say this. I certainly cannot claim that Revelation 16 identifies the modern State of Israel in this way.
But the possibility raises another question that I find even more disturbing:
What if the true Israel is yet to gather?
And then Paul whispers something rather unsettling into the discussion:
“For not all who are descended from Israel are Israel.”
Romans 9:6
That single sentence should, at the very least, make us cautious about assuming that the biblical word Israel, the modern political State of Israel, ethnic Israel and the people whom God ultimately recognises as His own are necessarily interchangeable concepts.
Paul himself forces us to ask the question:
What exactly does God mean by Israel?
What If?
I have asked this question in several of my treatises.
There are Christians who look expectantly towards the return of Christ after Armageddon.
Some therefore interpret events in the Middle East through an eschatological timetable in which a great final conflict must occur before Christ returns.
And this creates a frightening theological possibility.
What happens when people begin to want prophecy fulfilled?
What happens when Christians become eager for Armageddon because they believe that once the battle comes, Christ will return and all His enemies will finally be destroyed?
And then comes the question I almost hesitate to ask:
What if, in eagerly working towards the destruction of those they have identified as Christ’s enemies, they themselves become enemies of the Christ they claim to await?
What if?
Because Christ left us an extraordinarily inconvenient test by which to recognise His followers.
Not their ability to interpret prophecy.
Not their ability to identify geopolitical enemies.
Not their ability to predict Armageddon.
Love.
“By this everyone will know that you are my disciples, if you love one another.”
Perhaps one of the most dangerous possibilities in religion is that a person can become so consumed with defending God’s programme that he ceases to resemble God.
Sometimes the things I overhear in the Molue overwhelm the mind.
And then I remember something I once wrote about the Village Idiot.
It came from one of the many feisty exchanges I had with Gabi, my favourite Australian.
“You think too much about these things,” she once told me.
“Just breathe!”
Gabi, I should mention, was born to Jewish parents in Berlin in the dying days of the Second World War. She rejected religion about as completely as it was possible to do and was as staunchly anti-Zionist as she was pro-Palestinian.
We argued.
Boy, did we argue.
And during one of those exchanges, I wrote something in anger that, with a little refinement, went something like this:
The Village Idiot
The happiest of men may simply have given up trying to discover some greater meaning to life.
They gossip.
They laugh.
They sit together at the pub, beneath the village tree or outside the church after Mass.
And they are perfectly content to leave no footprints upon the sands of time, or whatever it is upon which human beings imagine they are supposed to leave footprints.
That’s what you suggest I be?
She responded, rather unkindly, with something along these lines:
Those who cannot simply sit at the end of the day in fellowship with others, amused and satisfied by the ordinary rhythm of existence, perhaps even by the possibility that their lives may ultimately have no greater meaning, may have condemned themselves to a peculiar kind of misery.
Perhaps they would be well advised to become like the village idiot.
And now, all these years later, sitting once again in the Molue and thinking about Israel, Armageddon, false prophets, frogs, signs, wonders, Christians, enemies and Christ…
I find myself wondering:
Perhaps Gabi was right after all.
Maybe I think too much.
Maybe the village idiot was really not an idiot?
Perhaps he was the only wise man among us!
Perhaps his idiocy, though entirely uncontrived, rested upon information sounder than that available to those of us who chose a different path.
RIP Gabi!
But what if? What if the greatest deception is the one that looks most convincingly like prophecy fulfilled?
What if those waiting most eagerly for Armageddon fail to recognise the spirits gathering the nations towards it?
And, most troubling of all:
What if, in eagerly working towards the destruction of those they have identified as Christ’s enemies, they themselves become enemies of the Christ they claim to await?
What if?
Don Kenobi
#MyFrancisEssays | #OldManInTheMolue



%20.png)



2.png)